A 3-Step Guide to Assessing Risk
Traditional valuation models operate under the assumption of a going concern, implying the company will continue operating without significant threats to its operations. This assumption is central to both discounted cash flow (DCF) and relative valuation methods. However, when a firm faces a significant risk of not surviving, these models can yield overly optimistic valuations. This article explores the importance of recognizing distress in valuation and outlines steps to adapt traditional methods for this purpose.
The Importance of Distress in Valuation
Distress, often stemming from excessive debt or an inability to meet operating expenses, can significantly impact a company’s valuation. It can truncate future cash flows and lead to a lower valuation multiple compared to healthy companies. Ignoring the potential for distress can result in misleading valuations and poor investment decisions.
Methods for Incorporating Distress into Valuation
Adjusting Traditional Valuation Models:
- Simulations: Probability distributions for key DCF inputs can be used to run simulations that factor in the possibility of distress. If the simulation results indicate distress, the firm can be valued accordingly.
- Modified DCF Valuation: Probability distributions can also be used to estimate expected cash flows, reflecting the likelihood of default. Additionally, using bottom-up betas and updated default risk measures can refine discount rate calculations.
- DCF with Distress Adjustment: Value the firm as a going concern, then adjust for the probability of distress and its consequences. This approach involves calculating a distress-adjusted value by considering both the going concern value and the distress sale value.
- Adjusted Present Value (APV): Value the firm as unlevered, then factor in the tax benefits and potential bankruptcy costs associated with debt. This method quantifies the net effect of debt on firm value, considering both its advantages and risks.
Relative Valuation with Distress Considerations:
- Comparable Distressed Companies: When using relative valuation, compare the distressed company to other distressed firms in the same sector. However, this method’s effectiveness depends on the availability of a sufficient number of comparable distressed companies.
- Distress-Adjusted Multiples: Adjust the valuation multiple based on observable distress indicators like bond ratings. For example, lower bond ratings would typically warrant a lower multiple compared to the industry average.
- Forward Multiples with Distress Adjustment: Estimate the going concern value using forward multiples based on projected financial data. Then, adjust this value by considering the probability of distress and the potential distress sale value.
Equity Valuation as an Option:
- Equity as a Call Option: In situations with substantial debt, equity can be viewed as a call option on the firm’s assets. This perspective recognizes that equity holders have a residual claim on the firm’s assets after debt obligations are met.
- Option Pricing Models: Utilize option pricing models like the Black-Scholes model to estimate the value of equity, considering factors like the firm’s asset value, debt level, volatility, and time to maturity of the debt.
A 3-Step Guide to Valuing a Distressed Company
Here’s a simplified three-step guide to applying the DCF with Distress Adjustment method:
- Value the firm as a going concern: Conduct a traditional DCF analysis, projecting future cash flows and discounting them back to the present value using an appropriate discount rate.
- Estimate the probability of distress: Determine the likelihood of the company facing distress within a specified timeframe. This can be achieved by analyzing bond ratings, using statistical techniques like probit models, or examining market prices of the company’s bonds.
- Estimate distress sale value: Determine the value of the company’s assets if sold in a distress situation. This value is typically lower than the going concern value due to factors like time constraints and market pressures. It can be expressed as a percentage of the book value or the DCF value.
Final Valuation: Finally, combine the going concern value, probability of distress, and distress sale value to arrive at a distress-adjusted equity value.
Key Considerations:
- Continuously update your valuation as new information becomes available, especially regarding changes in operating margins, cash flow, and debt levels.
- Recognize that equity in distressed companies can exhibit option-like characteristics, potentially trading at a premium to the DCF value due to the possibility of future improvements in the firm’s financial health.
Valuing distressed companies demands a nuanced approach that goes beyond traditional valuation models. By understanding the concepts of distress, adapting valuation methods, and carefully considering relevant factors, investors can make more informed decisions when assessing the risk and potential rewards associated with distressed companies.
Read Full Report
65 pages
Register New Account
• Loading times may vary •
